de quel StJulien s'agit-il?

..... 2003 St Julien 16.5 Drink 2010-16

Blackish crimson. Not much nose - is this because it is, in the way of a first growth, hiding its light under a bushel, or is it just flavourless? Lots of very ripe Merlot. Could do with a bit more structure. Inky tannins intrude towards the end but not a well-melded whole. Just lacks a vital spark. Certainly very ripe and well handled but not the usual ..........magic. Hollow before inky finish.
J.Robinson

un autre lui a décerné 95-100

un autre a déclaré "meilleur que le 2000 totalement surévalué"

maintenant vous savez de quel vin il s'agit!

ceci juste pour souligner que les avis entre pros divergent considérablement dans ce millésime 2003.

Léoville Barton

Lynch Bages & différents sons de cloche

Lynch Bages (FV 17.5) (WS 92-94)

is consistently one of our biggest selling wines and once again Lynch Bages delivers the goods. The Cabernet here was not picked until the very end of September and it is deep, powerful and ripe. A great, complex, mint, tar and cigar-box nose. Intense Cabernet character. Rounded and supple on the palate with a kick of tannin on the finish. Classic and delicious. “Very rich and decadent style to this. Full-bodied, velvety tannins and a delicious finish. Flashy wine. Long and seductive. Maybe even better in bottle.” WS

et....

Ch Lynch-Bages 2003 Pauillac 16 Drink 2008-20

Very healthy crimson. Notably fragrant, almost floral, but quite light. Skinny tannins and very marked greenness. Certainly not one of the successes of the vintage.
trad: certainement pas un succès de ce millésime

oui David!

Claudius,

Tu reçois les notes de Jancis Robinson ? Tu es abonné ?
Si c'est le cas, puis-je te demander de me communiquer ses impressions au sujet de Trotanoy ?
Merci.

David

toujours pour la rubrique différents sons de cloche:

Pontet Canet 95-100

Huge, thick nose. Incredibly dense wine. This is a real powerhouse infused with roasted black fruits and tannin. It has the density of the super-seconds without the polish. Hugely impressive but will require patience. “Full-bodied, very rich and powerful with massive tannins but it finishes sweet and ripe. This is muscular, but then it turns to crushed fruit. Super-seductive. The best Pontet I have ever tasted.” WS
le meilleur Pontet Canet dégusté jusqu'à  ce jour!

Ch Pontet Canet 2003 Pauillac 16.5 Drink 2009-16

Mid crimson. Dense. Hidden nose. Slightly overripe on the nose - a little Brule. Good acidity to compensate but not integrated. Not fine. Rather inky finish. And no great weight in the middle.
br^lé, bonne acidité mais mal intégrée....et pas de puissance en milieu de bouche

voilà  David

Ch Trotanoy 2003 Pomerol 17.5 2009-22

Unusually deep purple for a Moueix wine. Lowkey but convincingly subtle nose. Intense, well-mannered nose. Very well balanced. Slightly dry finish. Some very ripe notes but there is a freshness on the finish. Good for the vintage but will probably never be one of the great Trotanoys.

pour les autres: ne me demandez pas d'autres commentaires svp

Merci Claudius. (bbb)
Ne t'inquiète pas, je ne te demanderai pas d'autre commentaire.

Claude,

Juste encore un petit service, je sais que j'abuse mais bon, pourrais tu nous communiquer..... une autre devinette ?
Soulagé, hein ? (aaa)

Amitiés,
M@nuel.

allez M@nuel, je suis sympa....mais attention c'est très difficile

quel est ce vin?

...............19 Drink 2010-28

Fabulous stuff. Extremely deep purple. Very deep and dense in every way yet with wonderful freshness and vivacity. Rich, animal and meaty at first on the nose but then on the palate it's miraculously well defined and delineated. Great opulence but without a hint of overripeness .......... Great clarity. The tannins are beautifully ripe and carry through the tasting experience as opposed to sneaking in nastily at the end. There is a beginning, middle and end to this wine that is so refreshing it's like an energiser.

haha allez bonne chance!

J'sais pas, j'hésite .....
Je dirais Sociando Mallet, commentaire de Bernard Burtschy.
En fait, ce qui m'intrigue, c'est qu'il ait fait son commentaire ne anglais ??! J'comprends pas ! (aaa)(aaa)

Amitiés,
M@nuel.

Bonjour,

Ca doit encore être un commentaire de JR.

Quel bordeau rouge, difficile à  trouver, à  pu obtenir une telle note?

Allez je donne deux réponses ;

- Troplong Mondot

- Eglise Clinet

Horrow

Made in Japan?

Ben Montrose, non?

19/20!!

ca ne peut-etre qu'une star du bordelais? sinon, ca va etre dur, dur de trouver.

bravo Vince2! mais ne le criez pas trop fort

Ah oui, le fameux Montrose!!!

Et bien, si avec tous ca, il n'explose pas à  la hausse, je ne comprends plus rien!!